Foilio

Free tool

Should you grade it?

Grading can multiply a card's value — or quietly lose you money on fees. Put in the raw value, the top-grade comp, and your odds, and see the expected return before you ship.

“Value if top grade” is the comp for the grade you realistically expect (often PSA 10 / PSA 9). Be conservative on the chance — surface flaws are easy to miss.

Expected value after grading$131.00
Cost to grade (fee + shipping)− $25.00
Net if you grade$106.00
Sell raw instead$40.00
Expected uplift vs selling raw
+$66.00
Likely worth grading · top grade ≈ 2.8× your all-in cost

Rule of thumb: grade when the top-grade comp is at least ~3–5× your raw + fees, and you're confident in the card's condition. Estimates only — not financial advice.

When grading is worth it

Grading costs a per-card fee plus shipping and insurance, and takes weeks. It pays off when a high grade is both likely and worth a large multiple of the raw price. A common rule of thumb: grade when the top-grade comp is at least 3–5× your all-in cost (raw value + fees) and the card looks clean — sharp corners, no surface scratches, good centering.

Check a card's raw value first with Foilio's free search, and read how card value works.

Estimates for planning only — not financial advice. Grading outcomes vary; be conservative about condition.

Card Grading ROI Calculator — Should You Grade It? (Free) · Foilio